How the leveling works
1099 value = rate × billable hours − extra SE tax (~7.65%) − health premiums
W-2 value = salary + match (the salary already pays for PTO)
Each side gets credited what it really provides: the contractor's gross is haircut by the employer-side taxes they now pay themselves and the insurance they must buy; the employee's salary is topped up by the match. Paid time off isn't added on top — the salary already pays for those days — but it's why the contractor's billable hours should leave room for similar time off. What remains is honestly comparable money.
A worked example
$75/hr at 1,800 billable hours grosses $135,000; minus ~$10,300 extra self-employment tax and $7,200 of premiums, the adjusted value is ~$117,500. The $120,000 W-2 with a 4% match ($4,800) totals $124,800, and that salary keeps paying through 25 days off. The salary wins by about $7,300 — the contractor rate would need to be about $79/hr to tie. The 1,800 billable hours leave 35 unbilled days, which is roughly those 25 days off plus the gaps between clients. This is why "they offered me more per hour" is where the math starts, not where it ends.
When 1099 wins anyway
Real business deductions (home office, equipment, travel), a working spouse's health plan (zeroing the premium line), the ability to stack clients, and S-corp tax structures at higher incomes all tilt the table back toward contracting. Run your actual numbers above — the point is deciding on arithmetic instead of vibes. Setting your own rate instead? Use the freelance rate calculator.